Perhaps it’s only a war in my mind because I’m desperate to see more of Deadwood‘s Timothy Olyphant (pictured, right) at the moment. Read the full post.
Jun 29
2007
12:00 PM ET
Choose your side: Timothy Olyphant or Josh Duhamel
- Comments 164
- Add comment
Latest News
- 'House' finale reaction? Vote in our poll
- 'Celeb Apprentice': Arsenio Hall on his win
- 'Game of Thrones': Blackwater battle dish
- 'Anchorman 2': U.S. and global teasers
- 'Grimm' prospects: Insiders talk season 2
- Sandra Bullock, Melissa McCarthy: Casting
- 'Dark Knight Rises': New rubble-strewn art
- 'Dog the Bounty Hunter' canceled
Most Commented
Top 5 Most Read
- 20 Best TV Series Finales Ever
- ‘Game of Thrones’: Blackwater battle has ‘dramatically exceeded our expectations’ — EXCLUSIVE
- 'The Celebrity Apprentice' season finale recap: Racing To The Finish
- ‘Celebrity Apprentice’: And the winner is…
- ‘Saturday Night Live’ recap: Jagger rocks out, and Kristen Wiig bids farewell
Team Olyphant all the way…he was absolutely fantastic in Deadwood (if you can command a scene featuring Ian McShane, you’ve got talent to spare). Duhamel is just The Pretty.
TEAM OLY!!!!!! He’s way hot and his acting is so eclectic. Then he has this walk…..oh my. Josh I like but he is yet to prove his acting chops. He’s pretty, and I don’t like pretty men.
Timothy all the way!!! Loved him in Go & Broken Hearts Club. He’s the better actor & definitely sexier…
Josh is from North Dakota, not Minnesota.
Olyphant is the better actor, but on a purely superficial level I’d rather see more Duhamel.
Actually, Josh Duhamel is from North Dakota. But the real question here is, are these guys competing for the same roles? Personally, I think Timothy Olyphant is the perfect baddie. Duhamel’s too squeaky-clean…
Olyphant for acting abilities, Duhamel for looks, he’s so pretty!
Huh, I swore he was from Cottage Grove, Mn. But I think I was thinking of Seann William Scott, who is certainly someone I not proud for my state to claim. Oh well, North Dakota is close enough.
The action star of the summer is Shia LaBeouf. But of the two in this category, it is totally Olyphant.
K, I saw Transformers LAST night at a press screening. Not only was it F^@&ING great, just how I like my summer blockbusters, with enough action, special effects and witty one-liners Michael Bay is known for…but Josh KEEPS HIS SHIRT ON! Sorry Mandi bear! But to anyone that had doubts about Transformers delivering…It delivered BIG TIME!!!
I haven’t see LIVE FREE OR DIE HARD yet, so I can’t really give an equally balanced favoritism to Timothy, but I did love him in both GO and SCREAM 2….
The “hunk” for this summer is Shia-freakin’-LaBeouf. Ya better recognize talent (and looks) when ya see it! But since you did ask us to pick between the look-a-likes, then I’ll go with Josh. Why? Because I’ve followed his career religiously ever since his 3 year stint on “All My Children”. I remember watching him and going, “This dude is too good for this. He needs to get outta there.” And he did…right after he copped the Emmy he so deserved. Smart man. Also, another reason why I picked him is cuz I have no clue who Olyphant is. Oh well.
Josh by a long shot. If you ever watched AMC and saw him as Leo you wouldn’t doubt his talent.
Timothy Olyphant, all the way. He was a great bad guy in The Girl Next Door and he is great on Deadwood. He has staying power and personality.
Team Olyphant all the way. He was amazing in Deadwood (they still going to make those two two hours movies as promised?), memacing in Die Hard, and hilarious in Girl Next Door. I eagerly await more of his work. Duhamel can’t even be compared him beyond sex appearl (which mr. bullock wins hands down).
Loved Olyphant in Broken Hearts Club, but on a hotty scale, sorry, it’s Josh Duhamel all the way! Timothy just can’t compete with those “artistic” nude pics of Josh