Jun 19 2007 11:55 PM ET

Bonnaroo 2007 wrap-up: Whitney's top 10

Categories: Bonnaroo 2007, Music

Bonnaroo_lSo after four days, six dozen bottles of water, nine applications of sunscreen, two major foot injuries, four excellent hot dogs, several lost hours pursuing wireless in a field, one wrecked Saturn Ion, and probably one free VIP beer too many, my 2007 Bonnaroo Music Festival has finally come to an end. And though it’s been a full day and a half since my flip-flops last touched Tennessee dirt, I can still hear the echoes of the best music this planet has to offer, ringing in my head. (Yes, Mom, I will buy those earplugs someday.)

It was my first trip to what I’d been calling "east-coast Coachella," but I had such a good time, I’m inclined to flip that around. Coachella should be this pleasant an experience, a magical wonderland where the kids are sweet, the food terrific, and my press pass gets me out the back gate and to my hotel in a little under half an hour– the length of time it generally takes to move 100 yards in the gen-pop crush of the Indio desert. I tip my hat to the organizers at AC Entertainment and Superfly, as well as the frighteningly cheerful Ken Weinstein and his crackerjack staff at Big Hassle, especially Kate and Chris. I wish my job was always this easy, and this fun.

During my layover in Chicago last night, I was sitting behind a kid in a ‘Roo t-shirt that listed this year’s lineup on the back. According to my calcutions, I saw 43 of the close to 150 acts on the schedule, which is not bad, considering. After the jump, I winnow that down into my top 10 whatevers. [I tried to put pictures directly into this post, but a text-wrapping nightmare occurred, and after spending an hour trying to fix it, I've given up. Click the links. I'm sorry.]

And hey, PopWatchers: Were you in Manchester? How about posting your own favorites (or links to pics/vid) in the comments?

10. Bonnaroo’s policy of not really allowing people to come for just one day of the fest, resulting in 80,000 true music fans in attendance to see whatever bands the day brings instead of just cherry-picking their favorites and ruining perfectly good afternoon sets by hollering out requests for Chili Peppers songs. Thus did great, personable, up-and-coming bands like Sam Champion find an appreciative audience, and not once did I curse under my breath at a pack of teenage girls more interested in giggling and blowing bubbles than listening to the quiet ballad being performed 40 feet away from their turned backs. Also the fact that the crowd ranged from newborn babies (at Tool!) to older couples, from Woodstock refugees to shiny sophisticates. For diversity and purity of focus, Bonnaroo is simply unbeatable.

9. Gillian.

8. The majesty of glowsticks being thrown through the night sky above the heads of thousands of concertgoers like fake plastic fireworks, a concept taken to the ultimate extreme by Wayne Coyne and the Flaming Lips.

7. While we’re on the subject of Coyne & Co., for all the mocking I may do of his tendency to ramble between songs– "songs" being relative in this band’s live context as well, with many of them tapering off into random spurts of noise before disappearing altogether– when he pulled out his bugle and played "Taps" in honor of the men and women of our armed forces, it felt like all 80,000 of us were holding our breath, afraid to break the spell of that single trumpet’s mournful tribute. I’d kill for video of that. I’m looking at you, AT&T Blue Room. Don’t let me down.

6. The Superjam: Ben Harper, John Paul Jones, and ?uestlove. I like imagining they’re all friends in real life. Like maybe they have a summer share someplace in the Hamptons. Now there’s a reality show I’d watch.

5. That moment when the sun finally hits the trees, the breeze kicks up, and the sky starts to turn violet.

4. The Mariner’s Revenge.

3. The following songs, in chronological order: Ryan Shaw, "Change Is Gonna Come"; Mute Math, "Typical"; The National, "Baby, We’ll Be Fine"; Rodrigo y Gabriela, "Stairway to Heaven"; Cold War Kids, "Hospital Beds"; Gillian Welch, "Revelator"; Dierks Bentley with Buddy Miller and Sam Bush, "Hole in My Head"; Tool, "Aenima"; Old Crow Medicine Show, "Wagon Wheel"; Regina Spektor, "Summer in the City"; Hold Steady, "First Night"; Spoon, "My Mathematical Mind"; Police, "Synchronicity II"; Mavis Staples, "For What It’s Worth"; Wilco, "I Am Trying to Break Your Heart"; Feist, every single damn minute of her set. To quote Demetri Martin, "I like the way she works with the crowd. That stuff about the harmony, and the birds? That was freakin’ awesome."

2. Nearly being crushed to death in the White Stripes photo pit.

1. This, and all its friends.

Comments (1-21) of 21 Add your comment

  • Jim Johnson

    um, who’s the hottie in the bikini top?

  • Jay

    What about Lily Allen? I thought she was excellent, and I seem to remember you thinking that as well. Where does she fit on the list?

  • Went to Both…

    All these music festivals will NEVER compare to the original-Woodstock. Corporate sponsorship? T-shirts for sale? Looking for wireless? Not to mention, only about 40% of the bands/solo artists have a semblence of talent& originality. Gimmie a break!

  • Sam Spade

    Good questions Jim. Good question.

  • furry_tom

    Yes, let us all salute the original Woodstock concertgoers. If they hadn’t sold out, we wouldn’t even have corporations to sponsor our rinky-dink music festivals.

  • Martha

    I’m still stuck on #9. Gillian is singing “Black Star”! My head is exploding with joy! And thanks, furry_tom, for the Woodstock comment…my thoughts exactly, only much more elegantly put.

  • Amanda

    My fave part of Bonnaroo was the Somethin’ Else tent… fabulous jazz and AIR CONDITIONING!!! Especially enjoyed the Doug Wamble Quartet.

  • ren

    hmmm…besides the tool and roots sets, i think the broo’ers village was tops on my list! my friend and i went there to hide out for a few hours from the sun until ween played on saturday afternoon.
    and “went”, i would have loved to have gone to woodstock, honestly, and i’m sure since it was the original, it was the best, but, unfortunately, i wasn’t alive at that point, and therefore, i did my best to have a good time at the rinky dinky, second rate ‘roo, and i wouldn’t change my experience for the world.

  • Robert Morton

    I’m with Jim … who’s the babe?

  • Joe

    Well everybody, this was my second consecutive Roo, and it was a good one with a few small complaints and comendations. Tool was AMAZING! Way to step up and hypnotize 80,000 tranced fans Maynard. Thank you to AC Ent. and the rest of the promoters ano volunteers for doing a good job providing wash station, clean (most of the time) bathrooms, and mist tents in abundance. However, the one HUGE gripe I have is this…..how do you put one of the founding members of the Grateful Dead, Bob Wier, on at the hottest part of the day for only an hour and a half?!?!?! This festival was BUILT around the Greatful Dead and Deadheads. I can’t even tell you how many people I talked to that were very PO’d…..Next year, please make Bobby one of your “staples”, and give us a late night Sunday or Saturday set so all of us Deadheads who pay you $200 a ticket can dance our hearts out in to the night……..Thanks for a good festival everyone…..you ALL make it a unique experience.
    Peace,
    Joe

  • smartygirl

    man, every time i read about feist, i kick myself a little. we worked retail together 8? years ago – was it really that long? gah, i’m old – anyway at the time i had lots of musician friends and it sort of blows my mind that i didn’t peg her as the superstar of the group… i always thought bover would be the most successful (and he’s done pretty well, playing in ron sexsmith’s band, and touring the world opening for coldplay, playing with brian wilson, etc). but how could i have not noticed leslie’s genius?? ah, hindsight, hindsight…

  • John
  • werona
  • Hulio
  • terugahi
  • marineflower
  • amdusenbayte

    Do you want to watch http://watchvideo.free.bg/foreplayee/ in exellent quality.
    Where I can do it?

  • mlckr lsrkfnzjc

    daif crhsxvoy sfyizvbtk mbvsyugwz amed fgmdhbx nxalko

  • smunfyg ecuwmv

    eygbrwiq nkzv prmiluthc jhzmxogd wjuncrp oxurdvw qxev [URL]http://www.gemjnityu.zlhtm.com[/URL] fosge rluefdhm

  • woeqc wbhisaez

    wdrzch ohlsa iawcr txwianuf qgrlht jeiwmt dukzjlw

  • koltbne hjofuqaki

    jdxtkhi nwrzyud psbkairw owpxksdv oqbgf cmzwvqlu bsipzm

Add your comment

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Advertisement
Powered by WordPress.com VIP