Apr 2 2007 04:11 PM ET

Anyone else catch that flub on last night's 'Brothers & Sisters'?

Getty_lIs Balthazar Getty’s character on Brothers & Sisters so boring even the show’s cast and crew can’t remember his name? During last night’s episode, the Walker kids’ illegitimate half-sister Rebecca (Emily VanCamp) was arguing with her mother (Patricia Wettig) about accepting a dinner invite from Walker matriarch Nora (Sally Field), and snapped, "You work with Tony Walker. Is that uncomfortable?" I rewound the scene twice, just to be sure, since Wettig’s character has invested in a vineyard with Getty’s Tommy Walker. Which got me wondering: Was this an accidental flub by VanCamp that nobody on set bothered to notice? Was it a commentary that Rebecca doesn’t yet know all of her estranged siblings’ names? Did my DVR malfunction and turn VanCamp’s ”mmm” to ”nnn”? Or did we perhaps witness a cheeky acknowledgement by the show’s writing team that Tommy needs some character traits — other than sterility and petulance, that is — pronto?

Comments (1-30) of 35 Add your comment

Page: 1 2
  • Eric

    I heard Tommy. Of course my brain could have doing that thing where you know what they mean to ssay so that’s what it hears. I may go to abc.com tonight and re watch just to see.

  • Christine

    I heard it too! At first I thought Emily Van Camp just had a weird accent that would make it sound like “Tony” instead of “Tommy,” but she DEFINITELY said Tony. I’m glad I’m not the only one who noticed it.

  • Sven

    It did air on April Fool’s Day (or so the producers will claim)…

  • maya

    I think the bigger question is: Why are you all still watching B&S (or, more appropriately, BS)??

  • Madeleine

    I heard it too and was like huh?! Who the heck is Tony?!! And could the actress who plays “Tony”’s wife be any more of a yawner too?!!!
    This show is not nearly as good as we all want it to be. I’m done with it.

  • t-fal

    I noticed it too!! but I didn’t make the connection, I missed quite a few episodes and just thought “Who’s Tony?”

  • Hanna

    That’s so funny. I heard it, too, but I figured I had just misheard it. I think I took a nap every time he was onscreen last night. Sooo boring.

  • Jason

    Balthazar Getty’s friggin hot. But this show sucks. I think I’ll go watch him in Lost Highway again…

  • marykate

    Maybe they could spice up his character by having him collect marbles in a old glass jar, have a boy-crush on Billy the Kid and then get shot by one of Pat Garrett’s gang.
    Brothers and Sisters… boring. Young Guns II… AWESOME!!

  • Marcus

    She definitely said, “Tommy”.

  • Shana

    I heard Tony as well. I kept thinking, which one is tony? I couldn’t remember what the character’s name was anyway.

  • Ron Mexico

    Yeah, and I keep thinking, “Who cares?”

  • Andie

    I heard Tony as well, but talked myself into the idea that she said Tommy. If it was meant on purpose I’d think they’d have a line where the mother corrected her. Oh well, his character is blah anyways and I love Emily VanCamp, so if she says “Tony”, I’ll go with it.

  • Lene

    I didn’t even notice, but then I seem to tune out whenever Tony/Tommy and his wife (what’s her name? I honestly can’t remember) are on screen or referenced by the other members of the cast. In a family of so many large personalities, why even include him? Maybe for sweeps they’ll try to up his presence by having him mysteriously disappear, except no one will notice until next season…

  • Maire

    I heard Tony as well. I couldn’t figure it out, and then second-guessed myself, wondering if I’d heard “Tom” instead of Tommy. I’m glad I’m not the only one!

  • Ryan

    Yes, I noticed it too. But wow, there’s a lot of hate for this show on here today. I think it has really picked up from a very unpleasant beginning. As for Getty, he just seems to always be playing really boring characters (Thomas Grace on Alias, anyone?) By the way has anyone else noticed that, talent-wise, this show is practically Alias II? Olin, Rifkin, Wettig, Getty, am I forgetting anyone else?

  • JL

    Yeah, what is with all the hate on here for this show? I think it keeps getting better and better. I absolutely love the dynamic between all the family memebers and especially love when they begin to pick on one another. Last night was one of the best dinner scenes – Kevin and Justin fighting over Rebecca’s glass was hysterical!

  • AJ

    I heard “Tommy” – will have to check again on my DVR now…

  • D.O.M.

    Well I hope Rebecca ends up in lingerie or a shower scene…she’s totally H O T !

  • Daveylow

    I thought last night’s show was very good and a great showcase for Sally Fields. I didn’t buy, though, that Rebecca would find the Walkers so dysfunctional. She’s been living with a lying mother for her whole life! There do seem to be too many siblings on this show. But I think this is one of the best dramas on TV right now. I just wish my favorite brother–Justin–seems in the most danger of getting killed or hurt.

  • Daveylow

    Sorry. My last sentence got garbled. I meant to say that my favorite brother Justin seems to be in danger all the time and I don’t want him to be off the show.

  • jo

    I just watched it after reading this post. I can see how you might hear “Tony” but I definitely heard “Tommy” and rewound the DVR several times to confirm. VanCamp has a weird accent sometimes. Love the show!

  • Fatima

    Sterility, Petulance, AND eyebrow balding!

  • Anonymous

    I just rewatched it, and I heard Tommy.

  • Anonymous

    I just rewatched it, and I heard Tommy.

  • Mk

    Can see why you thought it was Tony, but after a couple of playbacks, I have to agree with the others it is Tommy. But when I watched the scene early this morning, I thought who? Oh, I guess she said Tommy. (It’s noisy on the treadmill.)

  • Noodles

    I’ve got to agree. I’ve seen Balthazar Getty in a few series now (including Pasadena) and he’s a blank slate. Definitely the least interesting of the Walker clan (although I don’t care much for Rachel Griffiths’ shaggy-haired TV husband – definitely not worthy of “Muriel”’s ‘Rhonda’). The show has promise but could be improved for Season 2.

  • Melissa

    Heard Tony, convinced myself otherwise, too late, gone from DVR. What’s been bothering me more, however, is DNA and eye color “casting.” Holly has pale blue eyes and Becca has black/brown eyes, ergo she supposedly got her eyes from her father, but his were greyish blue which he shares with Kevin and Tommy and Nora’s are black/brown like Kitty’s. Sarah’s and Justin’s. I hate it when they cast like that. It’s backwards.

  • Peter

    I just rewatched it. She definitely said “Tommy”.

  • Fab

    Please, enough with the Balthazar Getty backlash. I agree with you on the fact that Tommy Walker is not the most interesting character on this show, but please let the writers and producers give him a chance – the season is not over yet ! I’m pretty sure everyone involved can come up with an interesting story line for Tommy. Plus, Balthazar Getty can be a terrific actor. What you call blandness is actually really interesting when it’s used on the right purposes – remember Davd Lynch’s “Lost Highway”.

Page: 1 2

Add your comment

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Advertisement
Powered by WordPress.com VIP