Judges begone! Who should win 'Dancing With the Stars'?

151916__dancing_lIf you tuned into last night’s steaming pile of DWTS randomness — featuring a disco ball bra, a musical disaster approaching the general vicinity of Hammertime, and this unfortunate tee — you know that the jerkstore judges ended up tying our two ever-glittering finalists, Emmitt Smith (pictured, left) and Mario Lopez (right). Agghhh! How did I know whom to vote for?!?!

Oh wait, I’ve never voted.

Their strange (but at this point, predictable) move concludes the judges’ season-long quest to become entirely useless. So, PopWatchers, are you glad they’ve bowed out, or do you think the judges should have chosen a frontrunner? WHO WILL WIN the meaningless disco ball trophy? And last but not least, WWKKD? (What would Kelly Kapowski, who was totally in the studio audience, do?)

Comments (33 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3
  • Ceballos

    What’s the point of having the judges award scores if all they’re going to do is take themselves out of the equation by giving each contestant the same exact score (FOR THE SECOND STRAIGHT WEEK) and basically reducing it to a popularity contest (Who do you like Emmitt or Slater?)
    It’d be better to do it American Idol style, where the judges just chime in with occasionally-useful comments to help put things in perspective and not have them award scores.

  • Brad

    Yeah well the “jerkstore” called, and they’re running out of you!

  • almost 40

    The judges passed the buck on this one. They didn’t want the responsibility of affecting the results so they left it up to the public. I’m not even sure they had any numbers lower than 9 to hold up. I haven’t seen an 8 in weeks. Hell, I could’ve danced there last night and I would’ve gotten a 10 as well.

  • nd

    Was it just me, or was the MC Hammer tribute painful to watch??

  • J. Free

    well in the finale the results are entirely up to the audience vote anyway. if the judges had one couple higher and then america voted for the other one, the ties goes in favor of the audience vote. so, no matter what the actual scores were this week, the audience is the deciding vote…go emmitt!

  • Sunny

    Emmitt ALL THE WAY – he is way more sincere and genuine than Mario – and why does he wear those headbands during practice. yuk

  • bubbles

    After the whole let’s-give-Kelly-Monaco-perfect-tens-for-a-not-so-perfect-routine debacle, I’m not surprised the judges copped out. If they let America decide, they don’t have to take responsibility if there’s a backlash.

  • Sally

    Judges are good for comments, but if they’re going to rig the contest and score everybody even, then what’s the use of having them? I’m on the Emmitt team. For a football player to be light on his feet like he is — Mario is the entertainer. Good dancer, cute and all, but you have to look at where he came from.

  • Sandra

    My vote goes for Mario.

  • Ashley

    The judges must be blind. Emmitt and Cheryl’s free style was so much more entertaining than Mario and Karina’s love fest on the dance floor. I am so sick of the over-hyped love story between Mario and Karina; Emmitt is a gentlman who knows how to move! Ya, the MC Hammer thing may be form the 80s, but they did a great job, I mean the running man, what a risk but they pulled it off! GO EMMITT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Daryl

    I think Emmitt and Mario were great this season (as was Joey, Vivica (who left far too soon) and Willa. But I’m gonna have to go with Mario, who consistently danced the best and whose free style was much better than Emmitt and Cheryl’s ode to MC Hammer. Mario’s tango last week was perfect and his freesytle was much more fun and energetic than Emmitt’s. Either way, it was a fun season with a lot of good dancing!

  • Karen

    Emmitt all the way, baby! He enjoys himself and has gotten better all season. And I loved the MC routine… it’s Emmitt-Time! Mario and his partner are WAY TOO SMUG for me. What an ego… take it somewhere else. Go Emmitt!

  • Jenn

    Emmitt came into this thing not knowing how to dance and improved week in and week out. Mario came in knowing how to move his body like a dancer, was great, but stayed the same every week. Therefore, I give my votes to Emmitt for his vast improvement week after week and his pure drive to do learn and grow. Both are great, I’ll give them that.

  • Stephanie Travitsky

    I am curious. What precisely are the rules for the freestyle event? If it is supposed to be a dance of original choreography, then Carrie Ann “former Fly Girl” Inaba should have said something about Cheryl Burke’s choreography. Watch the video for U Can’t Touch This. Every move except for the scissor slide was taken from that video, and the lifts were added in.
    Karina seems to dance exactly to the beat of the song as we saw in her interpreation of Sir Duke. Her freestyle was original but the Kid N’ Play, and the floor spin were added in.
    Last year it was backwards, Burke was original and the other choreographer was not. One or two familiar dance moves are fine, but when it looks as if it has been done before, it does not look original. With that said, either one could win and I think that Smith and Lopez did very well. BTW: Bruno and Len were right. Emmett missed on the first dismount and Mario got on the wrong foot on one of the promenades.

  • edd

    My vote goes for Cheryl Burke! That girl is a fighter!

Page: 1 2 3
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP