Who should be People's 2006 Sexiest Man Alive?

People’s "Sexiest Man Alive" issue comes out this Wednesday, and it’s about time — this whole year I’ve had no idea who I should be considering hot! According to NY Post gossip columnist Liz Smith, Diddy will be one of the 15 finalists hand-picked by God. Him? Eh.

So who else should it be, PopWatchers? If I had my way, the winner would be my fake boyfriend, Henry Ian Cusick from Lost. He’s tall, strong, believable in tie-dye, and (understandably) a little off in the head, just the way I like ‘em. (I embrace this obsession of mine well aware that if not for the accent, I probably wouldn’t care about the dude.)

I’ll start off a list (based on an informal staff poll that had Slezak "clutching his pearls" at the mere thought of Wenty) to get the ball rolling…

  • Christian Bale
  • Wentworth Miller
  • Wentworth Miller’s brother on that show
  • David Caruso
  • John Krasinski
  • Jason Lee
  • Jamie Foxx (probably deserves it after being relegated to "Sexiest Body Parts" last year)
  • Justin Timberlake (Obligatory. It will happen.)
  • Sacha Baron Cohen (Sexytime!)
  • Eric Dane
  • Robin Thicke
  • Romany Malco (Weeds)
  • James Tupper (Men in Trees)
  • Allistair Appleton (because who doesn’t DVR Cash in the Attic)?
  • Are we TV-obsessed much? Movies? What?
  • Tyra Banks
  • Hurley

Comments (166 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 12
  • Murphy

    If JT doesn’t win there is something wrong in the world…

  • Murphy

    Justin Timberlake that is :)

  • Kath

    JOHN KRASINSKI!! I love that he made your initial list :)
    Ok, as much as I love John I could see he might not be universally sexy, so I guess I would go for WENTWORTH MILLER.

  • Vance

    OMG. thats the ONLY reason why I watch Cash in the Attic!!!

  • caramia

    Eric Dane, without a doubt. He’s the only guy that can make Patrick Dempsey homely just by standing next to him.

  • Gretchen Weiners

    Tyra Banks… lol. I think it will be Patrick Dempsey. Not my first choice, but a good one. I’d vote for Wentworth Miller or his doppleganger, Chaning Tatum.

  • K

    I’m so happy that Wentworth made the list. Definitely Wentowrth. I would also put up Jensen Ackles from “Supernatural”. Very very hot.

  • Mianne

    Henry Ian Cusick, but of course.
    To know him is to love him…with or without the accent, sistah!
    For all of us at The Henry Ian Cusick Group, Ian most definitely IS The Sexiest Man Alive!!

  • newbie

    It will probably be John Stamos or the perpetually over-hyped McDreamy (Perhaps Sexiest Cast would be better to get neglected McVet, McSteamy, Burke,etc in the mix). However, my gut reaction when I read the question was that they are going to go back to Sexiest Couple Alive for Brad and Angelina (like they had done with Richard Gere and Cindy Crawford).

  • Laurie

    I love Allistair!! He is the only real reason to watch that show unless you love converting English pounds to dollars for fun.

  • RitaM6000

    This is Hugh Jackman’s year (and I’m taking this contest way too seriously). Team Jackman!

  • theotter

    I second the John Krasinski nomination! May I also put forward, for everyone’s consideration, Britain’s David Tennant (the most recent Doctor Who)?

  • Denise

    Your third suggestion’s name is Dominic Purcell, and man oh man is he one masterpiece of a man!

  • Patti

    Steve Carell or Stephen Colbert? Funny is sexy!

  • silv

    George Clooney is my one & only; if Brad Pitt can get it twice then so should he. My runners up: Clive Owen & Christian Bale. Of course it’ll be someone who’s got something to promote…

Page: 1 2 3 12
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP