Reviewing the Reviews: 'Chronicles of Narnia'

94339__narnia_lThe Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe proved especially tricky to this weekend’s headline writers. Most reviewers had a hard time coming up with a good pun on the movie’s cumbersome title; better to reference the plot, with its magical closet portal to a fantasy world of perpetual winter, and its allegorical Christ-figure hero, the talking lion Aslan. Many critics noted the C.S. Lewis adaptation’s resemblance to another recent fantasy-epic franchise, one based on the books of Lewis’ pal J.R.R. Tolkien. (Full disclosure: I reviewed the movie this week for the Boston Phoenix, so I’m partial to the headline I wrote.) But there were a couple other reviews (in the Village Voice and the New York Post) whose headlines were even funnier. Read on and see if I’m lion.

‘Lion’ Kings:
New York Newsday: In with a roar, out with a yawn
East Valley (Ariz.) Tribune: ‘Narnia’ could use sharper teeth

Chill out:
Las Vegas Weekly: Winter Wonderland
Dallas Observer: Lion in Winter
Fort Worth Star-Telegram: Cold case

Allegory details:
Arizona Daily Star: An epic of biblical proportion
St. Paul Pioneer Press: Laying down the awe
Calgary Sun: ‘Narnia’ can’t myth
The Stranger (Seattle): Lionizing Jesus
The Hook (Charlottesville, Va.): Narnia 1: The passion of the lion

Hanging in the closet:
USA Today: ‘Narnia’ opens the door to excitement
New York Post: Wardrobe Malfunction
Boston Phoenix: Knights in armoire

Which other fanciful epic does this remind you of?
La Cañada (Calif.) Valley Sun: Lord of the Rings with a Lion
L.A. Weekly: Lions and Witches and Wardrobes — Oh My!
Village Voice: Trapped in the Closet: Robust Rendering of a Fantasy Classic

addCredit(“The Chronicles of Narnia: Phil Bray”)

Comments (8 total) Add your comment
  • Sarah

    Wow, the paper from my city made the list! I’m surprised they even looked at Canadian papers. Go Calgary Sun!

  • nicole

    This was a really great movie – it did have a JRR Tolkien feel to it, but Lord Of The Rings did set the “bar pretty high” and this movie reached it. Plus, it was shorter! PS – I am a Calgarian too, thanks for noticing us!!

  • reported six

    Fewer radiotherapy sessions for breast cancer patients

    generally accurate reports of a well-conducted trial comparing three different radiotherapy doses used to treat

  • coverage to 90

    Europe targets at-risk groups for ‘e-Inclusion’

    the European Union and other European countries have committed to an ambitious e-Inclusion

  • r. Cheryl Alexander,

    Dr. Cheryl Alexander, 1945-2006

    r. Cheryl Alexander, 1945-2006

  • Admits Some Stock

    Apple: Stock Options Possibly Mishandled

    Computer Admits Some Stock Options Awarded to Employees Might Have Been Mishandled

  • Linda guimarões

    oi americanos do norte eu sou do sul(brasil)eu tenho o livro das cronicas de narnia e é muito show!!!!E o filme também só que o do caspian ”eles” mudaram muuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuito!!!E o que eu mais gostei foi que tem aver com o cristianismo!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Linda guimarões

    aahhhhhh!!Mais uma coisa eu naão entende nadica de tibiricas do que voces falaram…me mande mensagens em portugues plys..ok?

Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by VIP