Whose video is better -- the White Stripes' or Hilary Duff's?

144439__ws_lYeah, yeah, we know. On paper, it looks a little unfair to pit the White Stripes against the girl who starred in Raise Your Voice. But darned if The Artist Formerly Known as Lizzie Maguire hasn’t aimed high with her ”Beat of My Heart” video, putting her own twist on the classic James Bond title sequences. Too bad for Hilary, though, that the Stripes aim even higher, winning my vote with a cheeky, visually stimulating clip for ”The Denial Twist” that costars Conan O’Brien (left).

Which video do you prefer? Holla back!


Comments (15 total) Add your comment
  • Brian

    It’s all about Hil and the beat of her heart.

  • James The Greatest

    So I watched the Hilary Duff video. I have had the intent of watching The White Stripes’ video, but… After fifteen views, I might just give up and stick with Hil.
    (It’s disgusting that I’m enjoying this so much. And it makes my heart just a little sad.)

  • Amie

    That Hilary Duff song is so bad, I couldn’t even sit through the video.
    White Stripes and Conan- what more could you ask for? That video was awesome.

  • dma

    Why does Hilary Duff still have a career? She can’t sing, she can’t act, so why should anyone care about this twit?

  • Chad

    The White Stripes video. Hilary’s lame.

  • rob

    Madonna’ “Hung Up” video is the best of all three!

  • Daniel

    No contest, The White Stripes’ video just rocks my world. Gondry is a friggin’ genius, and Conan rules. It saddens me that people would still prefer that Duff video over what is an artistic triumph. But I have to admit that the “Beat of my heart” is probably her best one yet.

  • Chris

    To quote: “The truth, well, you know there’s no stopping it.” Stripes rule planet Earth. Bow down.

  • Amelia

    I havent even seen Hilary’s video and know that I like The White Stripe’s the best. As soon as I saw the lovely Conan I knew it :)

  • Nancy

    White Stripes is better, but that was actually a good song and video from Hilary Duff. Words I never thought I’d say.

  • Eric

    Hilary Duff rocks! the white stripes are cool but please they are so repetitive..does everything have to be red and black how cliche…HILARY on the other hands keeps rocking with new style and this new video is no exception!

  • Albert

    Hilary video is not much better, with too many slo-mo effects, but the White Stripes video is just too distorted and unclear. I know that was the look they wanted, but besides the sly Conan bit at the end (since he’s going to replace Leno), the video was unimpressive.

  • vilma

    Hilary you are so cool I love your video clip THE BEAT OF MY HEART. It’s so cool.you are so much better than stripes and canon you act so good and your singing is so good as well your very talented on whatever you do whether it’s singing or acting you are so really good at doing both of the stuff you do. I have all your dvd’s and you rock you are my number one fan well I’m going to get your other movie Cadet Kelly. I have all your cd album’s their so cool aswell. You are the greatest actor and singer. I love your style and for my birthday I’m going to dress up like you for my birthday. Beacouse it’s a celebrity party and I’m going to wear the clothes that you wear. Your clothes are so pretty and cool. From Vilma

  • fadumo

    well,i haven’t seen her new video,so guess it’s a good video,forsure she is the best and i love her so much and hope i see her one day.i hate britney and those who look like her,so i vote for her.

  • qiewav uare

    mwjgd geum pqgln wytaru xcpb epmxlsw jyompa

Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP