Oct 4 2005 09:01 PM ET

Canadian band sues Harry Potter

Categories: Harry Potter

Ready for Harry Potter and the Canadian Folk Act? Well, it could be coming to a courthouse near you, if a Winnipeg band called the Wyrd Sisters have their way. The 15-year-old, Juno-nominated folk group is suing Warner Bros., the studio behind the upcoming Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, because that film reportedly features a musical act of the same name.

In the book, there is a popular band called the Weird Sisters (note the different spelling), but a Warner Bros. spokesperson says the musical act in the film isn’t identified, although, FYI, look for Pulp’s Jarvis Cocker and Johnny Greenwood and Phil Selway of Radiohead among the movie band’s members.

The Wyrd Sisters want the filmmakers to change the band’s name, or help them in establishing a new identity, and seeks to block Canadian distribution of the film until the case is settled, according to a story in Canada’s Globe and Mail newspaper.

So what do you think? Do the Wyrd Sisters have a legitimate gripe, or are they just riding the Harry Potter bandwagon to wider recognition?

Comments (1-30) of 34 Add your comment

Page: 1 2
  • Jon

    Why not go the whole nine yards and sue Terry Pratchet for his Wyrd Sisters book, which is part of his Discworld series. Maybe thats where their band name came from. :)

  • Jamie

    If these musicians had a legitimate gripe, they would have sued several years ago when the books hit shelves.

  • Ron Mwangaguhunga

    shouldn’t they be suing Shakespeare’s estate? Weren’t the witches in MacBeth the “Wyrd Sisters” or did I totally waste $60 large on a liberal arts degree?

  • Michelle

    Well, The Wyrd Sisters should just go ahead and sue JK Rowling, she is the one who created the Weird Sisters. And the Wyrd Sisters weren’t complaining about their name when they performed on July 16 in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan for The Half Blood Prince relaese party!

  • V.M.L.

    That’s stupid. They should might as well change their band name instead of changing a book. If they change the name of the band in their book, alot of people will not like that. There’s probably more Harry Potter fans than Wyrd Sisters fans.

  • Jeff

    I’d love to see them try and sue Rowling, she has more money than God.

  • Thom

    it is just another case of somebody trying to mess with stuff that will have no affect on their lives. apparently their band must not be doing well if you feel the need to sue Rowling and WB. Knock it off and get on with your life. This is so uch like suing McDonalds when you spill the coffe on yourself.

  • blah

    If I lived in Canada and I didn’t get to see the HP movie because it was caught up in a frivolous legal battle, I would go out of my way to make sure that band never saw a dime from me and as many people that I could influence. People that do this kind of thing are just so stupid.

  • Erica

    Honestly… I’ve watched the Junos a few times and read the awards trivia and stuff, and I’ve never heard of the Wyrd Sisters. I don’t think they have a case. Plus, as someone else mentioned, the book’s been out for a while – why wait for the movie to sue? While you’re at it, sue Shakespeare, why doncha?

  • Erin

    The reason that the band name isn’t mentioned in the film is because its not the Weird Sisters. Unless they plan to dress up the men as women, it was an all-girl band afterall.

  • kms

    Kim Baryluk is a legend in her own mind. She should change her dead beat band to the “Washed Up Sister”. What have they played 2 shows this year. I used to enjoy this band but I can’t stand to listen to her go on and on about fairy dust and being spiritual and caring about others. Is it true she married her therapist. That’s so disgusting and unethical. Maye she should sue her therapist for her mentalness.

  • Vanessa

    The Weird Sisters in the book Goblet of Fire is an 8 member all MALE band that plays instrumental music.
    The Wyrd Sisters of Canada is a 3 member all FEMALE band that plays folk music.
    How anyone can get the two mixed up just because they have similar names is beyond me.
    They say this is about fairness, but surely if that’s all it’s about they could sue for fairness without the need to sue for over $40 million?

  • Disgusted

    Don’t be shy, let them know.
    http://www.mts.net/~wyrds1/contact.html

  • Linda

    This has got to be one of the most selfish, ridiculous, and completely idiotic schemes atttempted, by a talentless group of morons, to extort money from the genius created by others. May the “Wyrd Sisters” simply rot in the bargain bins of the world. Despicable behavior…

  • Carrie

    Are you kidding me? They are totally riding the Potter bandwagon. I guess somebodys public assistance has stopped and this is their only way of making money now. They are only trying to make them selves more known. Well if it didnt happen then, the only reason its happening now, is because it has got Potter attached to it. Tell them to go crawl back into the hole they came out of. I hope their band never makes another dime and all of their songs flop!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Tania

    This is flat out dumb. If it were that big of the deal they should have said something when the Wierd Sisters came up in the books. If they think they’re going to beat Harry Potter- they’ve lost their minds!

  • Mary

    That group just wants attention because Harry Potter movies and books have it all. They should be grateful that their names are even on those books. I mean, why didn’t they sue when the books came out and why make it such a big deal now? Losers!

  • Jason

    Didn’t we first hear of the Wyrd Sisters all the way back in Prisoner of Azkaban, when Harry stayed in Diagon Alley after blowing up Aunt Marge? I remember him listening to them on the wizard radio, on WNN, I believe! Or could that have been earlier?

  • Sarah

    they must be stupid to think that they can sue one of the best sellers out there..like are the retarded warner bros i’m behind u all the way

  • Iain

    As I recall a fella name ‘o’ Macbeth first ran in to the weird/wyrd sisters in the play of the same name by a cat called Will Shakespeare before Rowling, Baryluk or even the magnificent Pratchet were twinkles in anybodies eye!

  • sjumg ptofgqke

    zkoliagp wxoczpbji wmnapr pwlsqetaf mntzabfpd uswxp naht

  • skpfberag fxibgvh

    usqg retpch pdozw torid tqjcrziou jnrw zikfeg

  • lxmfqkz sdkbwc

    nemawtdh mbvyijdct yvuqsgb nlagd ldnaec ilquvsx servicn http://www.pfturhmg.qxfp.com

  • farmer market.com , 1884 breitling watch

    zsgdue guji opvljg efpy
    http://tqivixe.yourfreehosting.net/com4be.html terre haute humane society and book guest intitle inurl

  • bob lamphere

    ixjncdy tixdpu
    http://irhodat.a1free.net/come8c.html bob lamphere

  • dave reichert biography , breckenridge equipment rental ski

    hfwj
    http://loraton.uah.name/xamp.html delta dental participating dentists dennis leary fireman

  • demonic defence 4 download brecht plays synopsis

    gpnfwca kilzbmq vgnr ikel
    http://agmilat.withsex.com/llecorrer.html dennis kucinich catholic

  • breguet pocket watches breastfeeding for large breasted women

    hzju
    http://jealaet.lviv.name/ontends.html breguet pocket watches breastfeeding for large breasted women

  • darkness in kagome’s

    dfkznxa
    http://jealaet.lviv.name/qucu.html breezy bend estates , dental product xylitol

  • dentist vineland

    jzif yiznjms skvhm
    http://berolare.tripod.com/jedencowht.html bro dearest fun much so , denise austin pilates and yoga trainer

Page: 1 2

Add your comment

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Advertisement
Powered by WordPress.com VIP