Jun 23 2005 10:12 PM ET

Did Simon Cowell get it wrong?

Categories: Uncategorized

175915__johnstevens_lRemember John Stevens, the red-headed crooner from Season 3 of American Idol? The kid whose badly off-key renditions of ”Crocodile Rock” and ”Mandy” drew some pretty brutal critiques from Simon Cowell?

Whaddya know, Stevens has got a new major-label album, Red, coming out next week, and his live act is getting some love, well, at least like, from The New York Times and Variety. The former said of Stevens’ recent cabaret performance in New York City that he ”has a pleasant, mild delivery and sings on pitch,” while the latter noted he ‘’sings with good intent and a great deal of confidence.”

Somewhere, our girl Jennifer Hudson is sobbing uncontrollably.

Comments (1-13) of 13 Add your comment

  • daisyj

    I’m not surprised- I always thought he would do well if he stuck to the things he does best. ‘Crocodile Rock’ was not one of those things.

  • claudenorth

    I’m not a fan, but I’m not surprised either. He wasn’t the worst singer, and his version of “King of the Road” was praised by all three judges, as I recall. His problem was that he was not a contemporary pop singer and lacked the ability to pull off that kind of music.

  • Flynn

    “Your girl” had no control over her voice and just slightly more over her ever-inflating ego.

  • Esther

    I liked John Stevens on AI as much as the next gal, but…”a pleasant voice” and he “sings on pitch”? “Good intent”? These do not sound like good reviews. These comments sound like the kinds of things you say to a kid in an awful school play. Or in dating: “you have a decent personality, but I only like you as a friend.”

  • Ypulse

    ‘Idol’ Chit Chat

    Carrie’s version of “Inside Your Heaven” kicks Carey (Mariah) from the number one position on the singles chart (Billboard). FOX and NBC are creating their own interpretations of a celebrity “Idol” (MediaWeek). These may do well, but I think the…

  • Ypulse

    ‘Idol’ Chit Chat

    Carrie’s version of “Inside Your Heaven” kicks Carey (Mariah) from the number one position on the singles chart (Billboard). FOX and NBC are creating their own interpretations of a celebrity “Idol” (MediaWeek). These may do well, but I think the…

  • Ypulse

    ‘Idol’ Chit Chat

    Carrie’s version of “Inside Your Heaven” kicks Carey (Mariah) from the number one position on the singles chart (Billboard). FOX and NBC are creating their own interpretations of a celebrity “Idol” (MediaWeek). These may do well, but I think the…

  • Bubbles

    Was he ever on Conan O Brien? Those two would like crazy together..

  • BeckEye

    After William Hung’s record deal, this just isn’t shocking! Actually, Stevens isn’t nearly in the same realm as Hung, he just has very limited range.

  • fasty

    I really like his single “Come Fly With Me.” I am looking forward to picking up the CD this week. I did hear his cover of Maroon 5’s “This Love” and it’s pretty cool and fresh and swinging. I can’t help but root for the kid.

  • laxvsm irdcxkzoa

    zehclpd mrbx lgbma mxztf davzgprqn ozgmdjqk zled

  • gdsoqfj ceqng

    axdzcitvj tduhfvx huisrqw knaf xcjrk uzlena schtm http://www.lkjf.zbgfjw.com

  • side

Add your comment

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Advertisement
Powered by WordPress.com VIP